Thursday, July 12, 2012

Army Cuts: A shift for the 21st Century.


Last week the Secretary of State for Defence Philip Hammond announced major cuts to the size of the British Army. Amidst battles to save the pound and the euro, improve Britain’s social infrastructure and keep the governing Coalition from falling apart in general, the issue of war and defence has taken a backseat. Is this a good move on the part of the government?

In a word, Yes. In general the 21st century has witnessed a major shift in attitudes to war. Where once the maxim of Carl Von Clauswitz that war was a logical extension of politics held precedence for a nations foreign policy, the same no longer applies. Since 1945 outright war has been the very last option a state seeks to enact and bar a few obvious examples in the last decade, major wars between states have been few and far between.

The creation of organisations such as the United Nations, trade alliances such as MERCOSUR and whole regions such as the Euro zone illustrates the distinct shift the International System has experienced in way of state interaction. Where once the system was defined by its wars and then its allegiance to a certain block during the Cold war era, the system now relies on cooperation. In an era where diplomacy and discussion takes precedence, the British government have taken the plunge and begun to dismantle what has become, since the Iraq war in 2003, a huge financial and PR drain for the government.

Some have been quick to criticise the move with the view that once cut, the Army will never recover and we will be severely weakened in terms of defence. Whilst I understand the argument, it is almost impossible to agree. Britain has long relied on alliances to boost its international strength. Without an Empire we would not have been considered a formidable power and the defeat of Hitler Germany only succeeded with the assistance of France, Russia and America. A more worrying move is the expansion of the Territorial Army. Whilst I understand the need for reserves, I am distinctly uncomfortable with the promotion of youths practising at playing soldiers.

I am in no way slamming the British Forces, who I think do an incredibly brave job, nor am I applauding the loss of thousands of jobs and livelihoods. However, when looking at the world today we need to ask ourselves, what need do we have a sprawling army? Surely we have other priorities.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

French Politics: Separation between State and Bedroom please.


Last week the latest saga in what has been described by the Telegraph as a “catfight” between the current and former lovers of France’s recent President Francois Hollande took a turn for the public and has raised interesting questions about politics and the roles that love, sex and infidelity have to play in the French political arena.

The tensions between Hollande’s former partner Segolene Royal and the current First ‘Girlfriend’ of France, Valerie Trierweiler, are no different to tensions that would surround any relationship between two women in one mans life. Yet what distinguishes this relationship and to a certain extent causes alarm is that all players are significant political figures and the prize is no longer Hollande but the French public. 

In the past we have seen politicians use the personal lives of opponents to win an election. No one will forget the infamous speech President Bill Clinton was force to make after his affair with an employee was discovered yet France has failed to recognize that whilst the public look to the women beside politicians, personal scandals can do no favours and the “C’est la vie” attitude we have come to expect just doesn’t cut it in current political climes.

Looking at last week’s French parliamentary election in which Royal was running, this is evident. With starkly different political policies to his predecessor and the recent questioning of relations between France and Germany, the French elections were an opportunity for Hollande to promote a sense of direction and calm for a general public clearly unimpressed with the actions of Sarkozy. Trierweiler, however, deflected any news of the political outcome with, what one can only suspect as, a calculated tweet in support of Royal’s opponent. Where Clinton, Obama, Cameron and all others would be in public overdrive, Hollande of course has said nothing.

Whilst Twitter is the forum in which meaningless isms are posted on a regular basis, the decision to open fire on issues relating to politics when they should be personal is a dangerous one yet one that frequently occurs in France. One has only to look at the history of the French monarchy to see how the indulgence in women and sex left government estranged to its people. And let’s not forget former President Nicolas Sarzoky, his high profile divorce and his marriage to former model Carla Bruni.

Marrying Bruni soon after his messy divorce to another presidential hopeful, Sarkozy portrayed a man more interested in women than in politics. In 2008 Sarkozy’s popularity was steadily in decline due to the view that the President was ignoring his country to have fun with his new wife. Sarkozy’s visit to England in 2010 was an opportunity to discuss a deeper relationship between the two countries, yet all politics was forgotten when a picture of a naked Carla Bruni went on sale at Christies. Whilst Sarkozy publicly showed disappointment one can only a suspect smugness in the man who paraded his wife around as an example of his pulling power.

Jacques George, author of Sex et Politique, has claimed when discussing France “To come to power, you have to seduce, and to stay there, you have to prove yourself vigoureux.” Is this the correct way forward? Should Sarkozy and Hollande have mixed politics and sex? Whilst every country has its scandals in parliament, one can’t help but think that France continues to take it too far.

It seems that England has trouble separating Media and State, America continue to confuse Church and State and France seem to think that the State takes place in the bedroom. Only time will tell if France will tire of the scandals of Hollande as they did so with Sarkozy. 

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Flowers for Harleys: The U.S.-Colombia Free Trade Agreement Comes into Effect

Written for The Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs and the Global Ethics Network.

Five years after its proposal, the trade agreement between the United States and Colombia came into force on May 15 with the export of Colombian flowers to the United States and an expected shipment of Harley-Davidson motorcycles to Colombia. It was a topic of contention at the 2012 Summit of the Americas that took place in the Colombian city of Cartagena: Will the free trade agreement fulfill the mutual benefits that boosters prophesy?

Proposed during the Bush administration, the free trade agreement (FTA) has been down a slow and winding road. With political divisions between Colombian President Juan Santos and his predecessor Alvaro Uribe, and the recent prostitution scandal that took place at the summit, the announcement that the agreement had finally come into force is a positive step for the Colombian government.

The recent shift, too, towards protectionism within Latin American countries such as Brazil and Argentina further places positive emphasis on the announcement of the trade agreement. According to The Economist, fears of Asian competition have led countries in Latin America to turn away from agreements and Mercosur relationships suggesting that free trade with the United States will benefit Colombia at a time when trade relationships elsewhere are facing pressure.

The agreement has, however, faced much criticism. The BBC reported that U.S. labor groups fear the agreement will lead to job losses at a time when workers can least afford it whilst Colombian Trade Unions fear Colombia is not yet developed enough to withstand such competition. Only seven months ago Colombian agriculture minister Juan Camilo Restrepo discussed the need to prepare small businesses and producers so that “when the cold shower of the FTA hits them, it doesn’t turn into pneumonia”. Is Colombia ready to open its doors to the United States?

TripleCrisis’s Kevin Gallagher suggests not. Arguing that Colombia will have to work twice as hard as the United States to benefit at all from the FTA, Gallagher uses the findings of the 2007 Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean to predict losses for Colombia in areas of “textiles, apparel, food, and heavy manufacturing industries, outweighing the gains from increased petroleum, mining, and other exports to the United States.”

The Free Trade Agreement between Colombia and the United States is presented as an opportunity for increased foreign investment in Colombia; whether or not the agreement will actually benefit Colombia in the way that it hopes still remains to be seen.

Further Reading:
“United States Must Redefine Fair Trade” Devin Stewart

“Drop the Free-Trade Blinders” Dani Rodrik

“Pragmatic Overdose: Ethics and creativity are stifled in the draft... Evan O’Neil

“A Human Rights Argument For The Colombia Free Trade Agreement” Susan Rice

“Marrying Trade and Human Rights” Susan Aaronson

“Local Produce Vs Global Trade” Adam Dean, Policy Innovations

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

U.S. Pledge to Afghanistan: National Security and Aid


The United States has pledged to support Afghanistan for ten years after the withdrawal of U.S. military personnel in 2014. The announcement of this partnership raises interesting questions about the nature of nation-building and aid, as well as U.S. interests in the state and region. While the partnership sends a message to the Afghan people that the West will not abandon them, it also sends a warning to the Taliban and neighboring states that a Western departure will not be an opportunity for them.

The announcement is timely given the recent controversies that have marred America's relationship with Afghanistan—the burning of Korans by U.S. soldiers, the recent release of photographs showing soldiers posing with Afghan bodies, and the murderous rampage of Staff Sergeant Robert Bales. The announcement of continued American support signifies an attempt to assuage such tensions while making a graceful exit, but is a long-term influx of American aid what is needed in Afghanistan?

Writing in the Guardian in November 2011, Bill Easterly warns of the American tendency to use development initiatives as opportunities to strengthen defense. Easterly suggests that the American habit of providing aid to war-torn and fragile states in the interest of national security is "misguided." Instead the focus should be on "areas with a better track record—health, education, infrastructure, and clean water and sanitation—operating in societies where war, repression and corruption do not make it pointless for aid to operate."

Perhaps a more potent question that rises from the American pledge is: Will it even work? Speaking at Carnegie Council in 2011, Francis Fukuyama discussed the problems that arise when outside influences attempt to help a nation rebuild itself: "I don't think we realize how difficult it is, how many resources it takes, and how long a process it is." Economist Dambisa Moyo is more specific in her criticism of outside influence, stating that the problem with aid is that citizens cannot hold their governments fully accountable as the agendas of aid donors often influence any decision made. In the case of Afghanistan, will the American partnership hinder government with hidden agendas or will Afghanistan benefit from the protection of the U.S from potential threats?


Further Reading:

"The Ethics of Exit from Afghanistan" Carnegie New Leaders Program: Katherine Brown, Robert Diamond, David C. Speedie



"A Look at Current U.S. Security Issues". Jeffery D. McCausland, Phillip McCausland

Monday, May 14, 2012

"Between men and women there is no friendship possible."


Oscar Wilde claimed "Between men and women there is no friendship possible. There is passion, enmity, worship, love, but no friendship." This is a wide generalisation and, as one could suspect, a comment meant to enthral his audience but perhaps Wilde was right on the mark in regard to friendship between former lovers.

Past experience has taught me that any break up is traumatic and damaging to at least one of the parties involved. What was once a connection that brings two people together can prevent any friendship from forming. Many have said that they have remained friends with old flames, but I wonder how truthful that really is. Can you remain friends with the person you have spilled your darkest secrets with? Your darkest thoughts?

CNN's Ami Angelowicz argues friendships can be maintained with exes in six simple steps. Can the human heart or mind really be diluted to six simple steps? I'm inclined to say no. Not for no reason have songs been written about the loss of a lover and the friendship that accompanies it.

I'm not saying that losing a friendship when you lose a lover is always a bad thing - in most cases it is a very good thing. I've always doubted the view held that you can get over a love and transform a relationship into a platonic one. Love is all those things listed in Wilde's declaration of relations between men and women - friendship could not compete with such memories creating complications and heart ache for all involved.

So perhaps Oscar should amend his exclamation of the relationships between men and women and say "Between old lovers there is no friendship possible."


Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Hollande and Europe: A change of direction or just a new face?

Written for the Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs and The Global Ethics Network.

The victory of anti-austerity Socialist leader François Hollande in the French presidential election has sparked discussion about the future of European economic policy. Winning 51.62 percent of the vote, Hollande's campaign was founded on the promise to introduce "a new direction to Europe," with a focus on growth and investment, in lieu of the austerity policies of outgoing French President Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel, which Europe followed in recent months to no apparent avail. Does his victory on these issues mark an end to austerity measures and an ideological shift across Europe?

Benedict Brogan of The Telegraph suggests that it does. He argues that the French election "gives the left in Britain a script to follow about an unpopular government detached from the people by wealth and austerity." Brogan indicates that the French election could prove problematic for Conservative British Prime Minister David Cameron, who has championed austerity measures in the past.

Although Jeff Sica of Sica Wealth Management asserts that the rise of Hollande marks the death knell for the French-German rapprochement seen under Sarkozy, on Monday German Chancellor Angela Merkel spoke of austerity measures "plus growth"—a nod toward Hollande's desire to focus on investment. Sigmar Gabriel, leader of the Social Democrats in Germany, stated Monday that the Socialist victory will "not only change France, but finally help Europe go in another direction." Facing criticism in Germany for her tough austerity measures, Merkel may be forced to soften fiscal policies.

New York Times columnist Paul Krugman has his doubts. He is pessimistic about an ideological shift in Europe, arguing that France's election is just a case of those on the outside benefiting from "the fact that they aren't in, and the economy stinks."

Perhaps a changing of the guards can only ever have minimal impact in the context of an economic crisis. As Jerome Roos of online magazine Roar succinctly puts it, "If the events of the past three years have taught us anything, it is that politicians do not rule Europe—financial markets do."

Whether or not the election of François Hollande will dramatically change the political landscape of Europe remains to be seen. However, his victory has raised questions about the success of austerity, and it opens the conversation to a diverse range of economic policies.

Further Reading:
Global Ethics Corner: Goodbye Euro?

Top Risks and Ethical Decisions 2011, with Daniel Altman, Ian Bremmer, Zachary Karabell, Art Kleiner, and Joel H. Rosenthal

"The European Union: Still a Global Power?" Zornista Stoyanova-Yerburgh, Carnegie Ethics Online.

"Euroland Crucified Upon Its Own Cross of Gold," Thomas Palley, Policy Innovations.

"The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth," Benjamin Friedman, Carnegie Council Public Affairs

Global Ethics Corner: The Debt Crisis: Are Politicians the Problem?

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

Cuba and Drugs Dominate the Sixth Summit of the Americas

Written for the Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs and The Global Ethics Network.

http://www.globalethicsnetwork.org/profiles/blogs/cuba-and-drugs-dominate-the-sixth-summit-of-the-americas

The sixth Summit of the Americas took place in Cartagena, Colombia on April 14–15 and raised some interesting questions about the future of U.S. policies in the region.

Global drug policy appeared to dominate center stage as the American "war on drugs" was criticized for its lack of evident success. Guatemalan President Otto Perez Molina encouraged the introduction of global drug market regulation, while Costa Rican President Laura Chinchilla advocated for legalization, and Mexican leader Felipe Calderon placed the onus on the United States to reduce demand.

Although a joint declaration was not produced at the summit, Markus Schultze-Kraft of the IDS Governance and Development blog commented that the 2012 summit was perhaps more fruitful than previous iterations: "Never before did a group of Latin American heads of state challenge the prevailing, US-backed drug policy orthodoxy with such solid arguments, political acumen and determination to find alternatives." This challenge to U.S. policy suggests a growing confidence to question American decisions in the region.

For example, U.S. policy toward Cuba and the country's exclusion from the Summit of the Americas also met resistance from the Latin American leaders. Calling the U.S. attitude toward Cuba a remnant of the Cold War, Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos said, "Hopefully within three years we will have Cuba as part of the summit."

With a more assertive South America can the United States afford to ostracize Cuba? John McAuliff of the Fund for Reconciliation and Development suggests not: "Bottom line, the Administration could have used the Summit to increase US stature by showing we have finally moved beyond the Cold War… instead we are at best going to stay even."

In March 2012, the Economist reported that Cuba is transitioning to a more capitalist system, and that Raul's successor will face growing pressure to respond to socioeconomic problems from a pragmatic perspective rather than a revolutionary one. Will Cuba be included in the next summit as Santos and other Latin American heads of states demand? With a growing and confident Latin America, the 2012 summit at least opened the debate.

Further Reading:

"A Moral Argument against the War on Drugs,"Julian Savulescu, Bennett Foddy, Practical Ethics.
"Globalization and the Financial Crises in Latin America,"Roberto Frenkel.
"Democratic Dilemmas in the U.S War on Drugs In Latin America (Case... Eva Bertram, Bill Spencer.
"The Cuba Wars: Fidel Castro, the United States, and the Next Revol...
"Digital Rations: Internet Policy in Castro's Cuba," Ellery Roberts Biddle, Policy Innovations.
"U.S Free Trade Agreement Won't Benefit Colombia,"Kevin Gallagher, Triple Crisis