Friday, December 14, 2012

Why Pink Floyd's 'Comfortably Numb' Perfectly Sums Up Today's Generation

Written for The HuffPost UK


On paper, modern British society has never had it better. We all have the vote, we have (more or less) equal opportunities, we have freedom of movement, speech, action, choice, everything.
Socially, women are becoming more and more prominent within businesses, class is beginning to count less and less in most circles and, thanks to the process of globalisation, we have access to different cultures, attitudes and resources. Materially, we have every gadget under the sun. Indeed, iPads, iPhones, Androids and Blackberries are all at our disposal and offer us the latest in media updates, games, social media and so on. Looking back even to 1990, the progression in British society is evident and, yet, we as a generation seemed to have regressed.
Politically speaking, voter turnout continues to decrease, student apathy towards politics, the government and current affairs has seemingly increased and even politicians seem uninterested choosing to leave Westminster in favour of the jungles of Australia as has most recently been done by one Conservative MP.
But it's not just politics. Society as a whole seems to be increasingly disengaged and dissatisfied. Self-help books are now seemingly published monthly, diagnosis of depression, anxiety and similar disorders are on the up, indeed the World Health Organisation's World Mental Health Survey Initiative found that in high income countries one in six were likely to experience depression, and more and more individuals appear to lack any direction or drive.
Why?
One possible reason is opportunity overload; Society has never had so many choices yet it is this breadth of choice that leaves us cold. Women are offered the opportunity to return to work once having children and yet it is this choice that leaves many so undecided - Which decision is the right decision? Similarly, with so much opportunity out there many struggle to choose and end up floundering as a result. More and more students leave university with no clue as to what they want to achieve in life and student unemployment is depressingly high. Furthermore, between April and June this year, the Office for National Statistics recorded a whooping 3.68 million living in workless households.
Searching for the one job, decision, action or material object that will make us 'happy' is made harder with so much on offer. Society has become so accustomed to having multiple options that today's generation is constantly striving for the newest 'thing' to make us happy. It's no coincidence that one of the world's greatest recessions since the 1930's has hit today's generation; the constant striving for more inevitably leads to over-zealous borrowing, lending and spending and look where that has left us.
Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle once argued that in order to achieve the scared goal of happiness, man must learn to accept balance. That is to say, it is only when we balance virtues and vices that are we truly content. Having too much of a good thing, then, is often not the answer. Written in the 1980's, Pink Floyd's hit 'Comfortably Numb' perfectly sums up our generation. With so much potential we should be striving ahead, actively participating and evolving yet having too much of a good thing has left us feeling alienated, unsatisfied, indecisive and numb.

Obama: The 'Audacity to Hope' Take Two?

Written for The HuffPost UK


Today President Obama in 2012 and James Bond have one thing in common; pressure to live up to the hype. 2012's Skyfall appears to have satisfied the critics but will Obama?
In 2008 Obama presented himself as the man to implement change. He declared that he would not use smear tactics to win the campaign against George W Bush, he declared he would end the War on Terror, he declared he would challenge the systems and he spoke of the American exceptionalism that sets the country apart from others. His inauguration speech was filled with determination and praise of America as a nation and his final words, "let it be said by our children's children that when we were tested we refused to let this journey end, that we did not turn back nor did we falter; and with eyes fixed on the horizon and God's grace upon us, we carried forth that great gift of freedom and delivered it safely to future generations" inspired many.
Look at 2012 and inspiration is low. America is facing challenges to it's supremacy from rising powers such as China, the War on Terror in the Middle East is still being fought - although Obama has since stopped calling it that, relations with countries such as Iran are tenser, the economy is still a problem and Obamacare is facing huge criticism and protest. The Presidential Election was deemed one of the most bitter in American history. As a result, Obama's campaign moved away from the positive and clean tactics of 2008 and shifted gear. The result was adverts raising questions about possible tax evasion, Romney's history and the 'dangerous' policies Romney would implement. It seems as if much of what Obama stood for four years ago has fizzled out.
Or has it? Have the failures to implement radical change been the fault of Obama and has he given up on all that he stood for? It is foolish to rule him out. America is difficult to crack. It's sharp division of powers often means domestically policies are slow to implement and push through, it's vocal and impatient public are often quick to criticize and the America that Obama inherited was not in good health. Much of what Obama is trying to implement goes against deep-rooted discourse in America, combined with a divided Congress, House of Representatives and White House, Obama is severely constrained by America itself.
The next four years offer a distinct opportunity for Obama. The second administration of any President is always different to the first. This is due to the fact that the President no longer has to worry about maintaining voters to win the next election and can push forward implementing the key policies they introduced in the first administration. So far we have heard much political rhetoric from Obama but very little political action - is this set to change? Looking at the recent campaign and political rallies, Obama's resolve appears to have hardened and with four years experience of the in fighting on Capitol Hill one can assume the Obama of 2012 is yet more determined to fulfil his promises.
If you look at the administrations of George W Bush, the second administration was more moderate behind closed doors than during the first. This has been attributed to the fact that Bush recognized in his first administration that being tough on terror was a vote winner whilst in the second administration there was apparent recognition of the failures of U.S foreign policy.
Obama has the opportunity to push forward and push for change once more. What is needed is not the politely cool President from 2008 but a determined one. Bill Clinton has called Obama "cool on the outside but burning for America on the inside" but what we need to see now is that burning on the outside. The next four years could see this change. Indeed, the campaign was different so might we hope for a more active administration? America has voted, Obama's future has been decided, what America needs now is ,to quote an old American favourite, 'a little less conversation, a little more action please'

Students and Politics: Are We Bothered?

Written for The HuffPost UK


Last week Liberal Democrat MP for Bath, Don Foster, participated in a panel debate held by the University of Bath's Student Union to discuss issues that directly affected the student population yet students failed to show any interested in the debate or the issues. Cast your mind back to 2011 and the student protests that took place nationwide and it might seem odd. The question I want to ask is, are we students really that bothered about politics?
The main topic of discussion was the controversial 'Article 4' - a housing strategy that proposes limitations being placed on houses available to students in cities with large student populations. Following the rise in fees one would expect students to rally around the issue of policies centered on limiting house availability and as a result potentially hiking rent prices, yet few students that were asked had even heard of the proposal.
With the upcoming national demonstration against university fees coming up in November many expected the debate to stimulate impassioned cries from the student population. However, the Bath student community has yet to decide if the Union will join the November demonstrations on their behalf. With issues directly affecting students becoming increasingly prominent nationally the question we should all ask ourselves is, why are we failing to engage in politics?
Blame has been placed on the parties themselves. The Liberal Democrats have faced the brunt of criticism with calls for Nick Clegg to step down as leader of the Party in the next election. The common cry is that Clegg and the Lib Dems have betrayed us. What should be considered, however, is that since the 2011 protests there has been little political participation to suggest that the majority of students are actively engaged in politics and the issues that affect them regardless of what the parties do. Certainly in Bath there is very little political participation.
Looking at past protests, such as those that took place last year, many appeared unsure of the issues they were protesting against. Of course, as a politics student myself I am not condemning the whole of the student population. Nor am I tarring all with the same brush. In certain pockets there has been engagement and many that protested were there as a direct result of the disappointment they felt at the rising fees. I am simply posing the question - are the majority of students interested in politics and if not how can we change this?
The recent trend towards using political gimmicks is not, in my opinion, the route to go down if British politicians wish to be taken seriously but with such an unengaged student population politicians need to consider how they can reach out to young voters.
Don Foster spoke of lowering the voting age to 16 but would this have any affect? A lot suggests that it wouldn't. Students seem to be less and less engaged in politics but is this the fault of the political parties? Bath University offered students the opportunity to voice their disappointment in policies implemented by the Coalition government and very few turned up. Is the fault of Don Foster? I don't think so. Last month Nick Clegg issued a public statement apologizing to students for agreeing to an increase in fees. Yet I am unsure that students have disengaged due to errors made by a political party. Disappointingly I think the majority of students just aren't interested in political issues and this is something that needs to be addressed on both a local level in student communities and a national level.

Euro Clashes: Will Internal Conflicts Damage the Future of Europe?

Written for The HuffPost UK


Much discussion between scholars has taken place on the topic of the European Union as a potential global power in a world where regions, such as the BRIC countries of Brazil, Russia, India and China, are becoming ever more prominent. The potential for the EU, and therefore its member states, to become influential international game players is certainly high and the Union has played an increasingly bigger role in international negotiations in recent years. However, to be a significant contender with global influence requires unity and coherence and a key question we should all ask ourselves is - are we there yet? Recent events suggests not.
During her visit to Greece last week, German chancellor Angela Merkel was greeted with violent protests against the current restrictive economic policies that Germany has proposed to help weather the storm of the Euro crisis.
These protests were to be expected. Certainly it is no secret that relations between Germany and Greece have steadily declined in recent years as a result of initial German reluctance to support the proposal of a Greek bail out in 2009. Yet whilst protest is healthy in democratic societies, the Greek population arguably took matters a step too far in comparing the policies imposed by Merkel to those of Adolf Hitler and revealed a fatal flaw within the European Union that could, euro pessimists would have you believe, ultimately lead to problems for the Union as a global contender.
The complete lack of unity between members of the European Union is a serious problem when attempting to formulate policy, resuscitate failing economies and compete with global powers such as China and the United States and was worryingly very evident last week. With current policies such as the 2008 Lisbon Treaty struggling to balance maintaining the Union, the single currency and the future of European foreign policy with a view to propelling the EU into the international arena as a global power, it seems relevant to ask - what hope can the Union possibly have if state antagonisms remain at the centre of how countries within the Union perceive each other?
By dressing up as Nazis, Greek protestors showed that, under pressure, states within the European Union revert back to suspicion and resentment of each other and historical grievances come to the surface. On a basic level, a state's national interest will always take priority over the interests of the collective but much of the future of the European Union relies on co-operation and unity. The recent episode in Greece suggests that perhaps the Union is not ready for such a commitment to each other.
The European Union was created with a common interest in strengthening regional relations and strengthening Europe's position on the world stage. It cannot be denied that positive outcomes such as the stabilization of much of Eastern Europe have resulted from the EU's creation and that today Europe has become a permanent feature in trade and has become increasingly significant in certain areas of international politics - Europe was the first to place sanctions on Iran following the perceived failure to comply with the Non Nuclear Proliferation Treaty.
Yet despite these successes, even when awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for creating stability and unity in regions such as the Balkans, member states appeared more interested in who would receive the prize than what the accolade meant for the Union's future image as a world power. The European Union has great theoretical potential and yet clear divisions between states still remain and until those are resolved - Europe can hope for little more than to remain a significant regional power with global power aspirations.

The Leveson Inquiry: Should We Care About Cameron's Response?

Written for The HuffPost UK


Talking to the BBC earlier this week, Hugh Grant expressed his fear that recommendations to change the way the media acts in society would fall upon deaf ears once the results of the on going Leveson Inquiry were released.
Set up to assess the ethical, practical and cultural factors of the media in today's society, the Leveson Inquiry has been closely followed by those that argue the media has overstepped it's boundary and become too powerful. Given that the media has long enjoyed the freedom to act as they please Grant is perhaps right to voice his fears. Showing a typically cautious response to controversial issues, Cameron has publically recognized the failures of the media sector but has been careful to remain ambivalent as to how far he would be willing to go to prevent the media abusing information available to them.
On the other hand, Grant and other critics of Cameron are arguably missing the point when debating how Cameron will act when faced with the results of the inquiry. Whether Cameron listens to the results and recommendations is of secondary importance at this very point in time. Any policies implemented will inevitably be a re hash of former policy in an attempt to appease a number of interested actors; a fact that political journalists should have realized at this point.
What is interesting and perhaps more important to come out of the inquiry is potential answers the inquiry will provide to questions surrounding what can be regarded as the public realm and the private, what information is allowed to be used and what isn't, what causes harm and what is infringement on an individuals right to privacy? Answers to these questions will have far more lasting an affect on the media culture and how society responds to the media than any direct policy by one specific person.
Since the early 19th century questions surrounding the divide between public and private, state and individual, intervention and freedom have influenced ideologies and politicians regarding how the state is structured. Arguably the most influential and recognizable figure regarding these issues was John Stuart Mill. Still very relevant to issues today, Mill argued against excessive state interference on the basis that society could be divided into to very distinct spheres (the private and the public) and that the state could only legitimately interfere in one - namely the public sphere.
For Mill, the public sphere was defined as those areas that affected society as a whole. If an individual's actions resulted in harm being caused to others then Mill would claim that the action should be subject to state interference. On the other hand, if an individual's action affected none but themselves the state could not interfere. For Mill, the individuals right to freedom of speech, press, action and involvement was critical to the well being of society and much of what Mill writes can be seen in the way the state has acted for the last two centuries.
Yet the recent scandals surrounding the media suggest that the division betwen public and private is not as distinct as Mill would like. Cameron himself has stated, "We don't want heavy-handed state intervention. We have got to have a free press. They have got to be free to uncover wrongdoing, to follow the evidence, to do the job in our democracy that they need to do."
In Mill's distinction, every individual has the right to freedom of speech and as such a journalist is doing no wrong in writing an opinion. However, when what is written causes harm, even if it is arguably necessary harm, can the press be regarded as entering the public sphere and therefore subject to state intervention?
Much of what has been discussed throughout the Leveson Inquiry relates to this issue. Were the press right to steal information from unwitting individuals in the search of evidence to back an opinion or a story. Is it freedom of speech, press and action for a journalist to write controversial stories that will inevitably lead to consequences for an institution, an individual or society as a whole? Will state intervention regarding the press infringe on our rights to personal freedom and is this a good or necessary result?
The story of Max Mosley is a good example. Many argued that Mosley's sexual antics were rightly publicized due to the idea that as a powerful man with high influence his actions could cause potential harm to the public. Yet many argued his private life, regardless of how colourful, should remain private and as such the media need to be regulated to prevent such incidents happening again.
What it boils down to is the question regarding what is private and what is public? What does the state control and who decides? In light of these questions, the potential answers the Leveson Inquiry will provide is far more compelling a result than Cameron's response. Hugh Grant, take note.

British Politics: Style Over Substance?


Written for The HuffPost UK
On Wednesday 26 September David Cameron became the first British Prime Minister to appear on a chat show in the United States. Chatting and joking with David Letterman, Cameron spoke of British ambitions and the crisis in Syria.
So far not groundbreaking news, but following the infamous publicity stunts of Mayor of London, Boris Johnson, in the weeks of the Olympic and Paralympic Games and the current culture of paying more attention to Theresa May's leopard print shoes or Samantha Cameron's new dress, this recent publicity move from Cameron raises questions about the way politics is presented and enacted within Britain today.
Across the pond the rise of John F Kennedy famously changed the way the game of politics was played out in America. His presidential campaign marked a step away from the traditional focus on matters of pure policy towards a focus on personality, publicity stunts, fashion and then - and only then - on political issues.
This year's Presidential campaign is no different. Barack Obama is a constant on American chat shows and make no mistake that, whilst it was entertaining and thoroughly enjoyable, Obama's rendition of Al Green's Let's Stay Together during his speech in New York a couple of months ago was most probably thought up by his clever PR team to reinforce his image of a cool and approachable president.
Is Britain going the same way? The era of 'New Labour' in the early nineties marked a transition phase. Whilst previous Prime Ministers Margaret Thatcher and John Mayor had maintained a sense of tradition within politics, even if the policies themselves often caused controversy, Tony Blair and the Labour party courted aspects of pop culture ("Cool Britannia") being photographed with popular TV actresses and musicians.
Fast forward to 2012 and Boris Johnson is being heralded as the next Conservative Prime Minister after becoming stuck in a zipwire and then being filmed dancing to the Spice Girls at the Olympic Closing Ceremony. For what reason? Because he makes people laugh, but should he be judged as a politician purely by these antics? Probably not.
Whilst political interest in Britain is declining and the turnout for general elections has been at its lowest for the past three political elections, interest in fashion and culture is increasing. As a result, British politics seems to be increasingly dumbed down to what its leading players are wearing or who they can be seen with.
Looking at country stereotypes Britain has always been presented as the stuffy older brother to America's fast paced, loud-mouthed youth. In Hollywood films, the British are often found wearing tweed, drinking tea and are often presented as cold hearted and traditional.
In most areas of life, we know that Britain is a far cry from these stereotypes: yes, granted, we drink tea, but we do have Cool Britannia, Kate Moss and the success of the 2012 Olympic Games to show that Britain can be more a contemporary to America. Despite this, though, politics and politicians have always maintained a distance from these more frivolous social aspects of Britain and this has, arguably, been to the benefit of society.
When a political leader spends more time worrying about who he should associate himself rather than the policies he should be enacting, it is ultimately the people that lose out. Look at today's dissatisfaction with political parties. Yes Samantha Cameron can dress to impress but satisfaction with the way the government works is at a gruesome low.
Politicians have always linked themselves with popular people for support but the problem today is that this is all politicians seem to focus on. Is Britain following American politics in its focus on personality and style over substantial policy change? Let's face it, in today's current climate we need politicians who know what they are talking about and although leopard print does suit Theresa, I'd far rather talk about her actions than her shoes.

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

U.S Pledge to Afghanistan: Will the presidential campaign alter things?


Featured in The Pryer.
The run-up to the United States presidential election is already upon us, with the recent announcement of Paul Ryan as the Republican vice-presidential candidate.

One issue that candidates have been less vocal about is Afghanistan and American military forces. Earlier this year Britain’s defence minister announced plans to cut the British forces by more than half amongst shouts in the House of Commons that Britain can no longer afford such an army. One wonders which route the American president will take, how this will affect Afghanistan and whether the US can maintain such a foothold in the Middle East.So far the two presidential candidates, Obama and Romney, have discussed the issues of the healthcare proposals Obama’s administration put forward (so-called ‘Obamacare’), the role of women in society and, only this week, a Republican party member was discussing the explosive topic of abortion.
Under the Obama administration, the United States has pledged to support Afghanistan for ten years after the withdrawal of U.S. military personnel in 2014. The announcement of this partnership in April of this year raised interesting questions about the nature of nation-building and aid, as well as continuing U.S. interests in the state and region.
While the partnership sent a message to the Afghan people that the West will not abandon them, it was seemingly also a warning to the Taliban and neighboring states that a Western departure will not be an opportunity to make mischief.
Cynically speaking, the announcement was timely for President Obama given the controversies that have marred America’s relationship with Afghanistan—the burning of Korans by U.S. soldiers, the recent release of photographs showing soldiers posing with Afghan bodies, and the murderous rampage of Staff Sergeant Robert Bales.
The promise of continued American support signifies an attempt to assuage such tensions while making a graceful exit, but one must wonder; if Obama secures a second term, is a long-term influx of American aid what is needed in Afghanistan?
Writing in the Guardian in November 2011, Bill Easterly warned of the American tendency to use development initiatives as opportunities to strengthen defence. Easterly suggests that the American habit of providing aid to war-torn and fragile states in the interest of national security is “misguided.”
Instead the focus should be on “areas with a better track record—health, education, infrastructure, and clean water and sanitation—operating in societies where war, repression and corruption do not make it pointless for aid to operate.”
Obama has continued an aid legacy that according to Easterly is ineffective, would a second term unhindered by the need to consider re-election prospects change this? Would Republican Romney offer a different perspective on the topic of aid and Afghanistan?
Perhaps a more potent question that rises from the American pledge is: will it even work? Speaking at Carnegie Council in 2011, Francis Fukuyama discussed the problems that arise when outside influences attempt to help a nation rebuild itself: “I don’t think we realize how difficult it is, how many resources it takes, and how long a process it is.”
Economist Dambisa Moyo is more specific in her criticism of outside influence, stating that the problem with aid is that citizens cannot hold their governments fully accountable as the agendas of aid donors often influence any decision made.
At the time of the announcement the main question was: in the case of Afghanistan, will the American partnership hinder government with hidden agendas or will Afghanistan benefit from the protection of the U.S from potential threats?
Today I am asking, will the pledge change under a new President and why are the candidates remaining quiet over an issue that until recently was front page news?